8 questions to ask before buying a new Shopify theme

8 questions to ask before buying a new Shopify theme

Choosing a new Shopify theme is a significant decision with many factors to consider. The abundance of options can be overwhelming, but fear not—I'm here to help you navigate through it.

Whether you're launching a new store, upgrading from a free theme, or giving your existing one a makeover, there are crucial questions to ask yourself. These range from assessing features and functionality to considering visual design and the developer's reputation.

Before we dive in, keep two things in mind: First, no matter the theme, your content is key. Even the most stunning theme won't shine without high-quality images and compelling content. Second, changing your theme isn't irreversible. While getting it right the first time is ideal, there's always room for adjustments.

Now, let's explore those essential questions together.

What are your must-have features?

Selecting a Shopify theme from Slash Themes is straightforward. Start by listing the features you can't do without. Do you prefer a clean and simple design, or are you more into bold and vibrant looks? Consider things like responsiveness, easy navigation, and compatibility with your products.

The key is to match your theme with your brand and the shopping experience you want to provide. If you're selling high-end fashion, go for a sleek and sophisticated theme. For quirky gadgets, opt for a fun and lively one. Keep it simple, and let your theme reflect your brand identity.

What's your budget?

Budget constraints are the reality check we all face. Before jumping into the theme options, figure out a budget that works for you. Fortunately, Shopify offers a variety of themes catering to different price points. While a free theme might be tempting, investing in a premium theme like the Mono Theme or Vivid Theme can provide you with more customization options, better support, and a unique look that sets your store apart.

See it as an investment in your brand's online vibe. A solid theme boosts conversion rates and keeps customers happy, adding up to a healthier bottom line.

What's already working?

Take a moment to reflect on your current website. What's working well, and what could use improvement? Analyzing your existing site can help you identify specific pain points and features that need attention. Perhaps your current theme lacks mobile responsiveness, or the checkout process is too complicated.

When picking a new theme, focus on features that solve these issues and make the whole shopping trip smooth. It's not just about looking good; it's about giving your customers a hassle-free joyride.

What are your competitors doing?

In the world of e-commerce, keeping an eye on your competitors is crucial. Visit their sites and note the elements that stand out. Is it their visually appealing product galleries, easy navigation, or quick loading times? While you don't want to copy their every move, understanding what works for them can guide your theme selection process.

By staying informed about industry trends and your competitors' strategies, you can ensure that your online store remains competitive and up-to-date. Your theme should reflect your unique selling proposition while incorporating successful elements from others in your niche.

How big is your product catalog?

The size of your product catalog plays a significant role in theme selection. If you have a vast array of products, a theme with robust navigation options and category filters is essential. On the other hand, if you offer a select range of high-quality items, a theme with a focus on storytelling and visual appeal might be more suitable.

Consider the scalability of the theme—will it grow with your business? As your product catalog expands, you don't want to find yourself limited by your chosen theme. Look for flexibility and customization to fit both now and later.

What are your featured products?

Highlighting your best-selling or featured products is a great way to capture your customers' attention. When choosing a Shopify theme, ensure that it provides prominent spaces for showcasing these key items. Whether it's a sleek carousel on the homepage or a dedicated featured products section, these elements can significantly impact your sales.

Consider the vibe you want for your featured products and see how the theme can bring that vibe to life. Whether it's a seasonal collection, a new product drop, or a special deal, your theme should be the stage for your brand's narrative and the essence of your top products.

What is your ideal customer experience?

Imagine you're the customer browsing your own site. What kind of online shopping experience do you want to provide? An intuitive navigation menu, easy-to-find product pages, and a hassle-free checkout process are all integral to a positive customer experience.

Choose a theme that enhances these aspects and creates a seamless journey from the moment a visitor lands on your site to the final click of the "Complete Purchase" button. Prioritize user-friendliness, as a complicated or confusing interface can drive potential customers away.

Who made the theme? Who supports it?

The creators and supporters behind a Shopify theme are as important as the theme itself. Look for themes developed by reputable companies or designers with a track record of creating successful e-commerce solutions. Read reviews, check forums, and gauge the level of support provided.

A theme is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and you may encounter challenges or have specific customization needs. Ensure that the theme you choose comes with reliable customer support, regular updates, and a community or support forum where you can seek assistance if needed.


Your Shopify theme is like the storefront for your online business in the ever-changing world of online retail. It's how customers see your brand, products, and their whole shopping journey. To make the right call, think about what you need, your budget, how your current site is doing, what your competitors are up to, the size of your product list, your star products, the kind of experience you want customers to have, and who's creating the theme.

Remember, your theme is not just a design choice; it's a strategic investment in the success of your online store. So, take your time, explore the options, and choose a Shopify theme that not only looks good but also works seamlessly to create a memorable and enjoyable shopping experience for your customers.

Back to blog